Imagine a border dispute with Mexico—hardly a flight of fancy in our current age of chaos—that halts cross-border trucking. The American supermarket, that glittering temple of consumer choice, would become a scene of panic within a week. The social fabric, already frayed thin, would shred.
Or consider a more pedestrian crisis: a blight, a drought, a new pestilence in a single, concentrated foreign growing region. Our supply chain, so long and thin, would not bend; it would snap.
And what of the integrity of the food itself? The Roman state went to extraordinary lengths to ensure the purity of the grain shipments to the capital. We, by contrast, have deluded ourselves into trusting a hopelessly overstretched FDA to inspect a deluge of foreign produce. We pretend that pesticides banned here, applied by labor working under conditions illegal here, somehow become safe once they cross our border. We have outsourced not just the farm, but a degree of our public health. This is a dereliction of the most basic duty of a government: to protect its citizens.
The Fallacy of the Cheap Tomato
The high priests of globalism will shriek that restoring our agricultural sovereignty will raise prices. They will weaponize the spectre of the expensive tomato to scare the consumer. This is the oldest, most cynical argument in their playbook.
First, it is a lie of omission. The price on the sticker is not the true cost. The cheap imported tomato does not include the price of our strategic vulnerability. It does not include the cost of a gutted rural economy. It does not include the cost of the social pathologies—unemployment, despair, dependency—that flourish in the hollowed-out towns of a once-thriving agricultural heartland.
The cheap tomato is a fiction, a down payment on a future disaster.
Second, the argument is an insult to the intelligence of the American people. We are not a nation of decadent children, demanding our strawberries in January at any strategic cost. We are, or once were, a serious people, capable of understanding that a marginal, seasonal price increase is a trivial cost for the security of knowing our food is safe and our nation is sovereign.
To invest in our own farms is to invest in our own people. A revitalized domestic produce sector means a revitalized rural America. It means jobs, not just for farmhands, but for welders, mechanics, geneticists, and robotics engineers. It means a renewed sense of purpose for communities that have been told for fifty years that they are obsolete. The dollar that goes to a farmer in Fresno, a grower in the Imperial Valley, circulates in those communities. The dollar that goes to a conglomerate in Mexico vanishes from our economy forever. The choice is not between a cheap tomato and an expensive one. It is between a strong, self-reliant nation and a weak, dependent one.
A Return to Prudence and Common Sense
This is not a call to build a wall around our grocery stores. This is a call for a return to prudence. It means that during the American harvest season, the American farmer has first claim on the American market. It is a simple, common-sense proposition that only a globalist ideologue could find offensive.
This requires scrapping the failed dogmas of the recent past and building a new framework based on seasonal, strategic trade. It means seasonally-adjusted tariffs that protect our farmers from foreign dumping during their harvest windows. It means a muscular “Buy American” policy for every school, military base, and government agency that spends taxpayer money on food. It means using the tax code to reward the giant retailers and wholesalers who choose to partner with American farms instead of foreign ones.
And it means we must finally get serious about the two things that have crippled American farming: labor and water. Our immigration system is a joke, a chaotic mess of unenforced laws and unworkable guest-worker programs that pleases no one. We need a rational, secure system that allows farmers to hire the legal labor they need, not create paths to citizenship. And we must build—the reservoirs, the canals, the infrastructure—to capture and move the water that is the lifeblood of our agricultural power. On both fronts, our leaders have for a generation done nothing.
The Soil of the Republic
We stand at a crossroads. We can continue down the path of managed decline, a nation of consumers utterly dependent on a fragile, foreign supply chain, our fate tied to the stability of countries we cannot control. We can continue to watch the slow erasure of the American family farm, and with it, a certain rugged, self-reliant character that once defined this nation.
Or we can choose another path. We can choose to believe that a nation’s strength is rooted, quite literally, in its own soil. We can choose to see the farmer not as a relic of the past, but as a sentinel of the future. We can relearn the timeless wisdom of the ancients: that a people who can feed themselves can determine their own destiny.
The work is hard precisely because it requires us to shed the decadent, comfortable illusions of the last half-century. But it is the necessary work of a free people. It is time to reclaim our harvest, and in doing so, reclaim ourselves.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Santa Barbara Current to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.