The Constitution Didn’t Fail. We Did.
America has a fascinating new national hobby.
We blame the Constitution for problems created by people who refuse to follow the principles that made the Constitution possible.
It is rather like blaming a boat because someone drilled holes in the bottom.
“The boat doesn’t work!”
No.
The boat worked for 250 years.
The hole is the problem.
The Founders warned us this would happen.
Not one.
Not two.
Almost all of them.
Yet modern America speaks of them as if they were a collection of confused old men who accidentally created the most successful constitutional republic in human history.
Apparently, they stumbled into greatness.
Pure luck.
Like monkeys typing Shakespeare.
Let’s perform a thought experiment.
Suppose you invent a machine.
You carefully write instructions.
You place warning labels everywhere.
You explain exactly how the machine operates.
You explain exactly what will destroy it.
Two hundred years later, someone removes every instruction, ignores every warning, smashes half the controls with a hammer, pours sand into the engine, and announces:
“The machine failed.”
Did it?
Or Did the Operators Fail?
That is America’s conversation today.
We are constantly told the Constitution is outdated.
The Founders were flawed.
The system is broken.
Democracy is in danger.
The republic is collapsing.
Perhaps.
But why?
Let’s ask a more uncomfortable question.
What if the problem was never the system?
What if the problem was the people?
John Adams famously warned: “Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.”
Notice what Adams did not say.
He did not say:
“Our Constitution was made for a wealthy people.”
Not educated people.
Not technologically advanced people.
Not powerful people.
Moral.
Religious.
Why?
Because liberty requires self-government before it requires government.
A free society assumes people will voluntarily restrain themselves.
They will tell the truth.
Honor contracts.
Respect property.
Keep promises.
Protect families.
Raise children.
Work honestly.
Serve neighbors.
Exercise self-control.
The government doesn’t create those virtues.
The government assumes they already exist.
That was the secret.
The Constitution was never designed to manufacture virtue.
It was designed to preserve liberty among a virtuous people.
But modern America has attempted something truly remarkable.
We removed the foundation and then expressed shock when the building developed cracks.
We Removed God from Public Life
Removed biblical morality from public discourse.
Removed personal responsibility.
Removed accountability.
Removed shame.
Removed consequences.
Then we held a press conference.
“Why is everything falling apart?”
A mystery.
Perhaps another commission should investigate.
Maybe a task force.
A blue-ribbon panel.
Three hundred million dollars and a 700-page report.
Anything except looking in a mirror.
Even our understanding of history has been turned upside down.
The Founders are often portrayed as vague spiritualists who happened to mention God occasionally between philosophical discussions.
Yet the evidence refuses to cooperate.
The Declaration appeals to:
Nature’s God.
The Creator.
The Supreme Judge of the world.
Divine Providence.
The Bible was the most cited source in political literature of the founding era.
Nearly every original state imposed religious qualifications for public office.
The Founders repeatedly spoke of religion and morality as essential to liberty.
None of this proves every Founder agreed on every doctrine.
That isn’t the point.
The point is simpler.
They overwhelmingly believed freedom required morality.
Morality required religion.
Religion Required God
Today we attempt to preserve the fruit while cutting down the tree.
We want liberty without virtue.
Rights without responsibilities.
Freedom without self-control.
Justice without truth.
Prosperity without work.
Blessings without God.
It is an ambitious strategy.
Results have been mixed.
Actually, that’s not true.
Results have been terrible.
But at least we have hashtags.
Modern society often behaves like a man who inherits a beautiful farm.
The fences were built by previous generations.
The fields are productive.
The irrigation works.
The barns are full.
The farmer immediately tears down every fence.
Sells the equipment.
Stops planting.
Stops maintaining.
Stops repairing.
A few years later he stands in a dirt field and asks:
“Who ruined this place?”
The answer is awkward.
The same answer America increasingly avoids.
The problem was never government.
Government cannot create character.
Government cannot create morality.
Government cannot create faith.
Government cannot create virtue.
Government can only reflect what already exists inside the people.
Which raises an uncomfortable question.
What if the crisis isn’t in Washington?
What if the crisis is in our homes?
Our churches?
Our schools?
Our communities?
Our own hearts?
Because a republic survives only as long as its people possess the character required to sustain it.
The Founders understood that.
The question is whether we still do.
Perhaps the Constitution isn’t failing.
Perhaps it is simply revealing who we have become.
And perhaps that was the warning all along.
“Blessed is the nation whose God is the Lord.” — Psalm 33:12
Paid Advertisement:
Community Calendar:
Got a Santa Barbara event for our community calendar? Fenkner@sbcurrent.com
Legal immigrants respect our laws and process for becoming American citizens and generally possess the virtuous character required of a free people. Illegal immigrants first act upon entering America is to thumb their nose at our laws. They do not possess a virtuous character and are inadequate to become citizens.
This says it all.