Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Polly Frost's avatar

An excellent piece, Andy. Two things I’d like to add. The first: Michael Shellenberger did a terrific talk on the subject here https://x.com/shellenberger/status/2002494700906033359. One thing that Shellenberger brings up is that Reiner himself could/should have used his Dem party clout to get Newsom to enforce laws that would protect both insane people and those they might harm. The second thing I’d like to add: we had an incident in October in Goleta that underscores the failure of our system to protect citizens from violence by mentally ill people. At the Ralph’s market in Magnolia Plaza, a mentally ill man tried to attack another man in the parking lot and stabbed the man’s dog. We knew about this man, who seemed to be homeless. We live near the open More Mesa field. In May, a young man knocked at our door, begging us to help him get his girlfriend to safety. This man was violently threatening them and the guy at our door had hidden his girlfriend and run (he was very fit) to our street for help. My husband helped get his girlfriend to safety as he asked the man to file a police report. The man and his girlfriend both refused. We called the police. They did a thorough search, but couldn’t find the mentally ill man.

Cut to October at Ralph’s when the mentally ill man attacked the other man, who wrestled the knife out of his dog and ran into Ralph’s. The mentally ill man followed and during the attempt to arrest him, the police shot and killed him. We shop at Magnolia. Only one hour before, my husband was parked right at the spot where the mentally ill man made the attack. It could have been my husband. And it could have been me, because often we park right there and I stay in our car with the window down while my husband goes into Ralph’s. I could have been stabbed in the neck by that man with no ability to defend myself.

I greatly resent the fact that this has never been adequately reported on in the Santa Barbara media. It has never been raised that this should not be happening in Santa Barbara. It should have opened questions about how to deal with our violent mentally ill people. Instead, there was a lot of sympathy for the mentally ill guy in our local Next Door and Reddit forums.

I feel sorry for the mentally ill. That’s why I want for there to be a change in the stupid “tolerant” ways in which our Democrat government is dealing — or rather, enabling violence from people who are not in control of their actions. It’s cruel to the souls of the mentally ill as well as their victims. As a psychiatrist friend of mine said to me “It’s definitely a big mess — I think there’s a lot of people who would be better off living in a supervised institution and that it would be better for the community as a whole as well.”

Jeff barton's avatar

In the last graph it appears that the incidence of mental illness was relatively stable until 2016 - 2017 when it began to increase and then in 2020 it appears that the slope or rate of increase in mental illness increased further. Beginning in 2016 the anti-Trump rhetoric increased and people were told that a candidate and eventual president was Hitler, going to put blacks in chains, has policies that are a threat to democracy, would accelerate global warming to the destruction of life on earth, etc. The increase in 2020 corresponds with the covid scam and the mass vaccination with an unsafe and ineffective therapy. I think it is enough to make anyone crazy.

85 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?