Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Anne-Marie Castleberg's avatar

Great comments. What is the plan to get rid of dead batteries?Lithium and all the others

Expand full comment
Jeffrey Wadsworth's avatar

Very interesting analysis and observations. One phenomenon, not mentioned, is how quickly people who have not studied the details jump onboard certain ideologies. In my career I had responsibility for large energy programs and attended and presented at many conferences. A simple conclusion that I reached was that in terms of energy production: “There is no silver bullet (although there maybe silver buckshot) and there is no free lunch”. On the first part, the world’s demand for energy can be met by a myriad of sources but that begs an answer to the second part which is at what price? Every energy production has a downside. The in-depth published technical analyses, including holistic approaches, come back to nuclear energy and natural gas (no free lunches I know, but they are simply the cleanest). We are starting to see the lack of holistic thinking in the examples cited by Mr. Caldwell, that is, wind energy and Lithium production, not to mention the role of pollutants in actually reducing warming. This is why holistic studies, not short term political policies, are needed.

Expand full comment
19 more comments...

No posts